Schuylkill Hub Search

First coal wave (1820s–1870s)

The English of Schuylkill County, Pennsylvania — Skilled Miners, Engineers & the 'Ranter' Chapel

The skilled coal miners, mine officials, and engineers of the first coal wave — and the “Ranter” working-class religion they brought. The most quickly-assimilated and least separately-documented of the county’s peoples. Markers: ★ verified · ✔ confirmed · ✎ corrects a common error · ⚑ open/caution.

Overview, with a necessary caveat

The English came to Schuylkill County in the same wave and for the same reason as the Welsh: they were experienced coal miners from the world’s leading coalfield, and they arrived to work — and quickly to supervise — the anthracite mines of the 1820s–1870s. Like the Welsh, they were a coal-era, not a founding-era, people; they concentrated in town (especially St. Clair); they supplied a disproportionate share of the skilled and managerial tier; and they brought a distinctive working-class religion, Primitive Methodism, that helped seed early unionism.

But the English present a documentary problem unique among the county’s groups: they blur almost completely into the Welsh in the record. Wallace, the borough histories, and the census habitually bracket “English and Welsh” together as the skilled, town-dwelling, Anglophone-Protestant British, and many “British” miners simply cannot be sorted into one or the other. ⚑ Worse for the historian (better for the immigrants), the English assimilated so fast and so completely — being Anglophone Protestants entering an Anglo-conformist America — that they have been called the “invisible immigrants,” dissolving into the American norm rather than persisting as a marked ethnic group. This profile is therefore as much about a role and a religion as about a separately-traceable people, and it says so plainly.

Sources: Anthony F. C. Wallace, St. Clair — “Immigrants in the coal region” (APS); Wallace — “Life in town”; Rowland Berthoff, British Immigrants in Industrial America (Google Books).

Where they came from, and the skill they carried

The English coal miners came from England’s great coal districts — Durham, Northumberland, Staffordshire, Lancashire — bringing pillar-and-breast working, timbering, ventilation, and the contract/sub-contract (“butty”) system of organizing underground labor. That expertise is exactly what let experienced Britons claim the top of the wage and supervisory hierarchy: in Wallace’s words, “Welshmen and Englishmen were able to move into the most highly-paid, highly-skilled work in the mines and to maneuver rapidly into supervisory positions.” ★

✎ A correction to a romantic but ill-fitting story. The famous Cornish “Cousin Jacks” were hard-rock metal miners (tin and copper) whose skills and diaspora belong overwhelmingly to the metal fields — Michigan’s Copper Country, the Wisconsin lead region, Butte, Montana — not to anthracite. The one period source placing “Cornish” men in the Schuylkill coalfield, geologist N. S. Shaler’s hostile 1873 Atlantic travelogue (“The men seem mostly Cornish or other British miners — shapeless, hulking fellows…”), uses “Cornish” loosely as a catch-all for “British miner.” ⚑ The firm claim for Schuylkill is English coal-district miners plus Welsh, not a distinct Cornish colony.

Sources: Wallace — Immigrants; Wikipedia — Cornish diaspora; Jake Wynn — “A Harsh Glimpse of Pennsylvania’s Coal Region, 1873” (Shaler).

The occupational role: from contract miner to superintendent

The structural point is Wallace’s, and it is well documented: the skilled, Anglophone, Protestant British supplied the county’s contract miners, fire bosses, inside and outside foremen, superintendents, mining engineers, surveyors, and colliery clerks — the literate, technical, managerial stratum of the industry. They were “nearly as concentrated in town” as the Germans and “recreated a network of community organizations similar to those they had left behind in Britain.” Town governance reflected this ascendancy: Wallace notes that “almost all of the members of the town council [of St. Clair] had English, Welsh, or German names,” with only one Irish councilman in the 1870s. ★

The single best-documented English-style figure is Samuel Harries Daddow of St. Clair (1827–1875) — ⚑ reported born in Cornwall, England (widely repeated but undocumented; see Open Questions), a mining engineer who emigrated to the anthracite region. He ran a “Miner’s Safety Squibs” fuse factory and a miner’s-cap factory and — more importantly — co-authored, with Benjamin Bannan, Coal, Iron, and Oil; or, the Practical American Miner (Pottsville, 1866), a landmark anthracite mining-engineering treatise: precisely the kind of skilled-technical contribution this profile is about. ★ (If his reported Cornish birth holds, it would place a Cornishman in the engineering/authorial tier of the county’s British miners, even absent a distinct Cornish mining colony — see the note above.)

✎ The blur made concrete: the marquee colliery at St. Clair, John’s Eagle Colliery, was leased from 1846 to William and Thomas Johns — brothers and Welsh immigrants. That the county’s signature skilled operators here were Welsh, not English, illustrates exactly why “English” officials are so hard to isolate from the broader British cluster. ⚑ (No specifically English-born named superintendent or 1870s county mine inspector could be pinned down in open sources; the full text of Wallace’s St. Clair*, Munsell (1881), and the PA Mine Inspectors’ Reports are the places to find them.)*

Sources: Wallace — Immigrants; Wallace — Life in town; Borough of St. Clair — history; St. Clair Coal Mine / Eagle Colliery (RootsWeb).

Primitive Methodism: “the coal miners’ special denomination”

The most distinctly English contribution to the county’s culture was religious. The St. Clair Methodists, Wallace writes, “mostly of English origin,” split between the conservative Wesleyan (Episcopal) Methodists and the Primitive Methodists, whom Wallace calls “not only a working-class church but the coal miners’ special denomination… Methodist as John Wesley had intended it to be,” and which “played a prominent role in nurturing radical unionism during the late 1860s.” ★

The denomination’s English roots explain the link. Primitive Methodism broke from Wesleyanism in 1811–12 after the open-air camp meeting at Mow Cop (1807) on the Staffordshire–Cheshire border, led by the carpenter Hugh Bourne and potter William Clowes; mocked by genteel churches as “Ranters,” the Primitives offered working-class evangelism with working-man local preachers, cottage worship, and Sunday-school literacy. The union connection is historically robust: Sidney Webb credited the Primitives, “particularly in County Durham,” with producing “an astonishingly large proportion of Trade Union leaders” — the archetype being the Durham collier, Primitive Methodist lay preacher, and pitmen’s-union founder Thomas “Tommy” Hepburn. This is the chapel-and-union culture the English carried into the anthracite field. ★

The First Primitive Methodist Church of St. Clair (North Mill Street) is the local monument of this tradition. ✔ Its dating is now clear — first meetings in 1831 (the first Primitive Methodist congregation in Schuylkill County and the first church of any kind in St. Clair), with the first dedicated building erected in 1847 — and Hugh Bourne is said to have preached from its pulpit around 1845. ⚑ Its claim to be “the oldest continuously operating Primitive Methodist church in America” is self-reported only: it appears on the local (St. Clair) record but is not corroborated by the denomination’s own national history (the first U.S. Primitive Methodist missionaries reached Brooklyn in 1829, so the “continuous” qualifier is plausible if older societies lapsed, but unverified). Alongside it stood the Wesleyan Methodist (Wade) church (1848) and Holy Apostles’ Episcopal (1847) — the Anglican option for higher-status English churchgoers.

Sources: Wallace — Life in town; St. Clair churches (RootsWeb); Primitive Methodist Church — Deep History; Wikipedia — Thomas Hepburn.

Labor, safety, and John Siney

The English (with the Welsh) “brought with them a tradition of organized labor learned in the coal regions at home,” and that tradition produced the county’s great labor pioneer — a man who perfectly embodies the English/Irish/Welsh blur. John Siney was born in Ireland (Queen’s County/Laois, 1831) but raised and trade-unionized in England: his famine-displaced family moved to Wigan, Lancashire, where he led the Brickmakers’ Association before emigrating to St. Clair in 1863. There he founded the Workingmen’s Benevolent Association (WBA) in 1868 — the first effective anthracite miners’ union, built on the British benefit-club and trade-union model — which grew to some 20,000 Schuylkill members. He died of miner’s consumption in 1880; about 1,500 attended his funeral, and the UMWA leader John Mitchell later made a pilgrimage to his St. Clair grave. ★ Siney is best understood as the bridge figure: Irish by birth, English by training, leading a union founded on the imported British model.

The English miners’ culture also fed mine-safety reform. The WBA had lobbied Pennsylvania into its first mine-safety act (signed April 12, 1869), but it was the horror of the Avondale disaster — 110 men suffocated on September 6, 1869, when a breaker built over the mine’s only shaft caught fire — that drove stronger ventilation, second-exit, and inspection laws, the inspectorate itself modeled on the British coal-mines inspectorate. ✎ Avondale was in Luzerne County, not Schuylkill — but the Schuylkill-born, British-modeled WBA drove the regional response, and Siney went to Avondale to urge the miners to organize. ★

Sources: Wallace — Immigrants; MarkerQuest — John Siney, St. Clair; Wikipedia — Avondale Mine disaster.

Assimilation: the “invisible immigrants”

The English assimilated faster and more completely than any other county group. Berthoff’s standard study, British Immigrants in Industrial America, 1790–1950, anchors the consensus: being Anglophone and Protestant, the English melted into a society whose assimilationist ideal was explicitly “Anglo-conformity” — American identity defined as English-speaking, Protestant, and Anglo-Saxon. They dissolved into the norm rather than persisting as a visible minority, which is why historians have under-studied them despite their large numbers. ★ The St. Clair town council, dominated by “English, Welsh, or German names,” shows the English not as outsiders but as the establishment.

The legacy is correspondingly diffuse. There is no “English neighborhood,” no surviving English-language ethnic press, no annual festival — the marks are a role (the skilled-and-managerial coal stratum), a religion (the Primitive Methodist chapel as the denominational fossil of “the coal miners’ special denomination”), and surnames so ordinary they read simply as “American.” It is the quietest of the county’s cultural stories precisely because it succeeded most completely at becoming invisible.

Sources: Berthoff (Google Books); “US Immigrants and the Dilemma of Anglo-Conformity” (Socialism & Democracy); Wallace — Life in town.

Open questions

  • Named English-born mine superintendents and the 1870s Schuylkill-district mine inspectors, from the full text of Wallace’s St. Clair, Munsell (1881), and the PA Reports of the Inspectors of Mines (1878).
  • Verification of S. H. Daddow’s birthplace and of the St. Clair Primitive Methodist “oldest in America” claim (and the 1831 vs. 1847 dating).
  • Any way to disaggregate English from Welsh in the St. Clair census beyond the surname guesswork — e.g., birthplace fields.

Sources

Frequently asked

Why are the English of Schuylkill County so hard to trace?
They blur almost completely into the Welsh in the record — historians and the census habitually bracket 'English and Welsh' together as the skilled, town-dwelling, Anglophone-Protestant British — and, as Anglophone Protestants in an Anglo-conformist America, they assimilated so fast they have been called the 'invisible immigrants.'
What was Primitive Methodism's role in the coal region?
Wallace calls it 'not only a working-class church but the coal miners' special denomination' that 'played a prominent role in nurturing radical unionism during the late 1860s.' The First Primitive Methodist Church of St. Clair, with first meetings in 1831, is the local monument of this tradition.
Were the Cornish 'Cousin Jacks' anthracite miners?
No. The Cornish 'Cousin Jacks' were hard-rock metal miners (tin and copper) whose diaspora belongs to the metal fields, not anthracite. The firm claim for Schuylkill is English coal-district miners plus Welsh, not a distinct Cornish colony.

Towns: Saint Clair, Pottsville

Related peoples: Welsh

People: John Siney (1831–1880), Samuel Harries Daddow (1827–1875)

← All cultures & peoples · Census spine →