The Capitol Theatre

The Capitol Theatre opened at 218–220 North Centre Street in November 1927, a Spanish Colonial Revival movie palace on the Comerford circuit. Historic-structures.com records it as seating roughly 2,700 and describes it, in its day, as one of the largest movie theatres in Pennsylvania. When sound came to Pottsville in 1928 it was the Capitol — not the older, independent Majestic down the block — that received the talkie equipment, and for half a century it was the heart of downtown movie-going.

The building’s design is recorded inconsistently: some accounts credit the theatre architect William Harold Lee, while others attribute the original building to the theatre specialist Leon H. Lempert Jr., with Lee responsible only for a later remodeling. The attribution is therefore best treated as unresolved. ⚑

The theatre Pottsville chose to lose (1982)

The Capitol closed in 1977 and deteriorated; its roof eventually gave way. In 1980 it was placed — individually — on the National Register of Historic Places, a higher distinction than the Majestic’s standing as one contributing building among hundreds in a district. Yet two years later the city tore it down.

The demolition was a city redevelopment project, paid for with a federal Urban Development Action Grant and tied to a mayoral “gameplan” that called for a parking lot on the Capitol site. Because federal money was involved and the building stood inside the National Register–listed downtown district, the project triggered the Section 106 historic-preservation review that normally forces a consultation meeting to seek alternatives. That meeting never happened: the review was handled, as one Advisory Council representative put it, “probably only through the mail.” The justification came in three voices — the city’s economic-development director called the listing “erroneously placed,” a federal Advisory Council program-review official reportedly called the 1980 listing “a mistake,” and the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission held that the building had “lost its integrity.” The marquee and facade came down in mid-August 1982, and the lot became the Capitol Parking Deck.

The same year the Capitol fell, the Pottsville Downtown Historic District was added to the National Register: the city gained its historic district and lost its largest theatre within the same twelve months. Today the fullest surviving record of the building is the set of Historic American Buildings Survey photographs the Library of Congress holds, taken as it came down.